Is it possible to cancel the purchase of an apartment? Termination of an apartment purchase and sale agreement - terms and guarantees


Grounds So, as mentioned above, the following may serve as grounds for termination of the contract:

  • mutual consent of the parties;
  • a significant change in the conditions of one of the parties;
  • other conditions provided for by law or contract.

However, the law provides for another basis for termination of a transaction – its voidability or nullity. General provisions on the voidability and nullity of transactions are given in Art. 166 of the Code. Thus, an agreement that is recognized as such as a result of a court decision is voidable, regardless of such recognition, it is void. Thus, the court, at the request of the party whose right was violated, may recognize the transaction as invalid if it establishes the facts that serious violations were committed in relation to the applicant’s rights protected by law.

How to terminate a real estate purchase and sale agreement after registration?

The property may have already been transferred (although it is also very imprudent to transfer the property before receiving payment), but the seller has not seen the money for it. Then he can write a statement of claim to the court and demand that such a transaction be terminated. In any case, the statement of claim must be correctly drawn up.

If you have doubts about the correctness of preparing such a document, it is better to contact a professional lawyer. Negative consequences of termination of a house purchase and sale agreement for the parties There is one very interesting point in Article 453 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

It says that upon termination of the contract, neither party can demand the return of what has actually been performed, unless otherwise provided by the agreement.

Termination of the real estate purchase and sale agreement. When can I cancel a deal?

In case of voluntary cancellation of a transaction, drawing up an agreement is possible until the terms of the contract are fulfilled in full. It is also necessary to mention the period given to the parties to make a decision in the event of receiving notification of the desired termination from the other participant.

By default, this period is thirty days, but may be specified in the notification itself. It is important to pay attention to such wording as “reasonable terms”, which relates to the time of transfer of property/money.


This period is not clearly regulated by law. Therefore, it is advisable to specify in the contract an exact deadline for fulfilling obligations under the contract. Judicial practice Termination of real estate purchase and sale contracts is accompanied by quite extensive judicial practice.


Most often, the reason is failure to fulfill the terms of the contract regarding the transfer of an apartment or money.

How to terminate a purchase and sale agreement for an apartment

Rosreestr will make an entry about the cancellation of the entry based on a court decision. Grounds for terminating a house purchase and sale agreement If the parties terminate the agreement by mutual agreement, then their motives can be absolutely anything.

People could simply change their minds, weighing and evaluating everything again - this is their right. The situation is completely different when the parties demand unilateral termination of the contract.
This process, as stated above, must be carried out exclusively through the courts. The party that insists on terminating the deal must prove that the other party, who wants to keep the agreement in force, is materially violating the terms of the deal.


What is meant by “significant violations”, see below:

  • The seller presented false documents in relation to the apartment.

Termination of a real estate purchase and sale transaction after registration

Attention

When terminating a contract due to significantly changed circumstances, the court, at the request of either party, determines the consequences of terminating the contract, based on the need for a fair distribution between the parties of the costs incurred by them in connection with the execution of this contract. 4. Changing the contract due to a significant change in circumstances is permitted by a court decision in exceptional cases when termination of the contract is contrary to the public interest or will entail damage for the parties that significantly exceeds the costs necessary to execute the contract on the terms changed by the court.


Article 452. Procedure for amending and terminating a contract 1. An agreement to amend or terminate a contract is made in the same form as the contract, unless otherwise follows from the law, other legal acts, the contract or business customs.
2.

When can I terminate a house purchase and sale agreement?

Important

If the documents have not yet been submitted to the Registration Chamber, no additional actions are required - the parties simply enter into a termination agreement in the same form as the main agreement. If the procedure has already been launched, the rules established in Art.


31 Federal Law No. 218. Thus, on the basis of Part 1 of this article, termination of state registration before making an entry in the Unified State Register is carried out on the basis of a joint application from the seller and buyer of real estate and a termination agreement. No other documents are required to be provided. Statement If one of the participants in the process significantly violates the terms of the contract, or there are facts indicating that the transaction is invalid, the interested party must, within 3 years from the date of discovery of the violation of the right, file a claim with the court, providing documents confirming the claim.

When can you terminate a purchase and sale agreement for an apartment?

There must be serious reasons to “cancel” a contract in court:

  • Violation of important (essential) clauses of the contract;
  • Other cases (determined by the court separately for each precedent).

Essential conditions, the violation of which leads to termination or invalidation of the document, most often are:

  1. Lack or incomplete payment;
  2. Encumbrance in the form of citizens registered in the apartment;
  3. Signing documents by an incapacitated person;
  4. Coercion to sign documents.

During what period can a purchase and sale agreement for an apartment be terminated?

Dear Anastasia. I beg to differ with my colleague. The law provides for the termination of an agreement, including the purchase and sale of a room. In my practice, for example, the court terminated the agreement for the purchase and sale of an apartment (and was not declared invalid) on the basis of a significant violation of the terms of the agreement. You should also know that it is possible not only to terminate the contract, but also to declare it invalid on the grounds specified in Articles 168-179 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Article 450.Civil Code of the Russian Federation Grounds for amendment and termination of the contract 1. Amendment and termination of the contract are possible by agreement of the parties, unless otherwise provided by this Code, other laws or the contract.
2.

When can you terminate a house purchase and sale agreement?

The reason for this lies in the peculiarities of the sale and purchase agreement itself and in the nuances of registering rights to real estate with state registration authorities. According to the Civil Code, the sale of an object can be terminated either in court or by mutual agreement of the parties.

However, mutual agreement may not be enough. Why? Let's consider an example: The parties completed a purchase and sale, the seller transferred the property, and the buyer paid for it in full.

The parties submitted documents for state registration, within the prescribed period the buyer became the owner, and the seller ceased to be the owner. At that time the parties did not make any claims against each other.
But then they changed their minds and decided to cancel the sale of the apartment.
So is it possible to terminate the purchase and sale agreement for an apartment after registration? In such a situation, two options are possible. If the parties mutually agree, they can conduct a reverse transaction. That is, a contractual agreement is concluded, but now the former owner-seller acts as the buyer. Another option is acceptable with the sole expression of the will of the participant. He can go to court, but only with a claim to declare the contract invalid. Moreover, you will need to provide compelling arguments. Otherwise, the court will not be able to terminate the contract unless its terms or legal provisions are violated. Agreement on termination of the purchase and sale agreement for an apartment When drawing up an agreement on termination of the purchase and sale agreement, the parties must provide for all important nuances, writing them down in the terms of the agreement.

When can you terminate a house purchase and sale agreement?

There are situations that are not at all amenable to a reasonable or legal explanation: “The court was considering a case of termination of the purchase and sale agreement due to changed circumstances. In particular, the plaintiff seller demanded to terminate the contract for the reason that his health had significantly deteriorated due to his advanced age and at the same time his financial situation had deteriorated.

Within one year, the plaintiff suffered a heart attack and stroke. That is, he could not imagine such a deterioration in his life. The court considered the grounds to be the most significant changes that allow the contract to be terminated. The precedent is that eleven years have passed since the conclusion of the agreement.” To summarize, it is, of course, possible to terminate the purchase and sale agreement. Moreover, this can be done over a fairly long period.

It is important to describe in detail the procedure for returning what was fulfilled under the contract unilaterally, and to specify the terms for return. What is it? A purchase and sale agreement is a document of agreement under which one party, the owner of property, transfers it to another person in exchange for an agreed amount of money.

The agreement is drawn up in writing. It describes in detail the conditions for interaction between legal entities, namely:

  • date of drawing up the contract;
  • identification data of the parties to the transaction;
  • the subject of the contract and its similar characteristics;
  • transaction value;
  • payment procedure and terms;
  • rights of the parties and their obligations;
  • responsibility of participants;
  • additional conditions.

The law provides for the mandatory presence of essential conditions in the policy.

Termination of a purchase and sale agreement means termination of its validity.

The money is returned to the buyer, and the goods are returned to the seller, as a result of which the trading relationship between the parties ends.

The procedure for terminating the contract is prescribed in Chapter 29 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

Termination of a contract for the sale and purchase of an apartment, vehicle and other goods is an act of will, the effect of which is aimed at terminating an agreement that has not been properly executed.

Termination of the purchase and sale agreement occurs in the following cases:

  • at the initiative of the buyer or seller;
  • by agreement of the parties;
  • the terms are violated by one of the parties;
  • A similar requirement is put forward by some government agencies (this happens, for example, if the terms of the transaction contradict antitrust laws).

If defects in the product are discovered and these defects cannot be eliminated, the consumer has the right to demand that the product be replaced with a product of the required quality, reduce the purchase price or terminate the contract, as stated in Article 18 of the Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights.

Chapter 29 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation makes it possible to terminate the purchase and sale agreement. This article contains the following provisions:

  • reasons for termination (Article 450);
  • termination due to changes in circumstances (Article 451);
  • order of procedure (Article 452);
  • legal consequences (Article 453).

The legal basis for real estate transactions is Federal Law No. 122, which states that real estate transactions (purchase or termination of a contract) must be registered.

But the law becomes invalid as of January 1, 2020. State real estate is registered in the manner established by 218-FZ.

Ownership and other rights to real estate and transactions with it, restrictions on rights, encumbrances of real estate must undergo the state registration procedure.

For residential real estate, there is a “double” registration process - transactions and changes in ownership.

Let's take a closer look at how to terminate a contract.

If the registration process has not yet been completed, the real estate transaction is considered incomplete. At this stage, it is easiest to terminate the contract.

The buyer and seller who refuse obligations must submit a termination agreement to the Unified State Register before the expiration of the deadline for registering the transaction and changing ownership (usually these stages are registered simultaneously).

Unified State Register of Rights to Real Estate and Transactions with It, containing the necessary information about the property:

If the parties sought the help of notaries or a real estate agency to conclude the contract, they should return here to terminate it.

If the purchase and sale agreement is in the process of registration, but registration has not yet been completed, the seller and buyer fill out an application to terminate the registration of the agreement with Rosreestr.

If one party refuses to terminate, the second party may sue if the refusal is in writing.

The process of terminating a real estate purchase and sale agreement after registration is somewhat different.

You can cancel the transaction after the contract has gone through the registration procedure, the money has been transferred to the seller, and the object has been transferred to the buyer:

  • at the request of one party;
  • by agreement of all parties.

If the seller and buyer reach an agreement, they can enter into another agreement: the buyer acts as a seller, the seller acts as a buyer.

The parties will re-exchange the object and money, and the transaction will undergo another registration, which will return everything to its place.

The termination agreement is signed upon reaching mutual agreement. It is registered based on the application of the parties. A note indicating the termination of the transaction will appear in the unified state register of rights.

If the parties partially fulfilled the transaction and the transfer of ownership rights was registered, the agreement to terminate the contract will not become the basis for the return of the apartment or other subject of the transaction.

If the desire to terminate the transaction is one-sided, a pre-trial agreement should be reached with the other party: you can send a written proposal to terminate the contract.

If the first party receives a written refusal or does not receive a response within the deadline (30 days), a lawsuit can be filed.

Just wanting to end the deal is not enough. There must be good reasons (Article 450 of the Civil Code):

  • the terms of the contract have been significantly violated;
  • other cases provided for by the Civil Code of the Russian Federation or the provisions of the agreement.

A significant violation of the provisions of the transaction entails damage to the other party, depriving it of what was due to it at the conclusion of the contract:

  • payment was not made or was not made in full;
  • registered citizens remained in the apartment;
  • documents were signed by an incapacitated person;
  • the person was forced to sign documents.

The buyer must pay for the purchased goods. Payment for real estate is confirmed by a document certifying the transfer of money:

  • receipt;
  • bank statement;
  • a receipt for depositing money into the cash register, and so on.

If the buyer refuses to purchase the goods, the seller has the right to demand termination of the transaction and keep the property.

If the property is transferred, there is no payment, the court will decide:

  • terminate the contract and oblige the buyer to return the property;
  • recognizes the transaction as illegal, obliges the buyer to pay the seller the required amount, as well as the amount of the penalty.

If the property is transferred to another person, the encumbrances remain: the debts are paid by the new owner of the apartment.

If a citizen who is not the owner of the apartment, but has the right to use the premises, is sent to prison or leaves for a long time, the owners can sell the apartment.

But after a certain time, the buyer may be faced with the need to share the property with the returning person.

If three years have not passed since the purchase of the home, the new owner may demand to terminate the contract and receive the full amount paid to the seller.

Invalid transactions

In judicial practice, a dissatisfied party often demands termination of a signed agreement on the grounds of its illegality or invalidity.

If the court confirms the illegality of the execution of a document, such contracts are not terminated, but are declared invalid.

Common cases are transactions that were concluded by incompetent persons, and contracts concluded under threat, under the influence of delusion or deception.

If the court recognizes the transaction as void, the participants return to the previous property status that existed before the start of the trade relationship.

The emergence of circumstances essential for the termination of the concluded contract is a situation, if they knew about the occurrence of which the parties would refuse to conclude the transaction.

In what cases can a contract be terminated without consequences? To cancel all the consequences of the concluded agreement, the court must recognize the situation:

  • appeared unexpectedly;
  • irresistible;
  • entailing serious damage to the parties;
  • affecting the interests of both participants.

If all four of these signs are combined, the changes are significant.

Essential circumstances:

  • changes in legislation;
  • significant increase in market price;
  • financial crisis;
  • liquidation of the enterprise (which is not related to the bankruptcy process).

In many situations it is possible to reach an agreement without going to court. Before going to court, you need to send a claim with a proposal to change or terminate the contract.

Reasoned claims can be considered by the other party, which is ready to compromise. Participants can reduce the price, change other conditions or terminate the contract.

The termination agreement is drawn up in the same way as the original agreement. If the agreement has been notarized or has undergone state registration, the agreement is also certified by a notary and undergoes state registration.

Upon termination of the preliminary contract for the purchase and sale of real estate, the funds received as an advance must be returned.

The preliminary agreement records the intentions of the parties to conclude the main purchase and sale agreement on the terms determined by the preliminary agreement.

Termination of a car purchase and sale agreement in 2019 occurs:

  • By the tribunal's decision;
  • in case of a significant violation of the contract by the parties;
  • in case of significant breach of contract.

The reasons “I changed my mind” are not weighty enough.

But the damage to the buyer was not always caused due to the seller’s dishonesty. Breakdowns occur due to wear and tear of parts that the seller may not have been aware of.

Therefore, the contract can be terminated by mutual agreement. The termination agreement is drawn up in the same way as a contract.

The agreement must contain the following:

  • information about the parties;
  • number, date of conclusion of the agreement;
  • the phrase “all obligations will cease mutually after its termination”;
  • date, signatures of the parties.

The document must be accompanied by an acceptance certificate for the vehicle indicating the absence of claims regarding the condition of the vehicle.

Victims often have a question about how long it takes to terminate a contract.. Article 196 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation regulates that the general limitation period is three years from the day the victim learned of the violation of his rights.

If the buyer notices defects in the product that were not specified by the seller, he may demand (Article 18 of the Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights):

If the buyer throws out or loses a cash receipt or sales receipt, this is not a basis for refusing to satisfy the consumer’s requirements.

The seller must accept goods of inadequate quality and check the quality of the goods, if necessary. The buyer can participate in checking the quality of the goods.

If, after inspection, it turns out that the defects of the goods occurred due to circumstances for which the seller is not responsible, the buyer shall reimburse the costs of inspection, storage and transportation of the goods.

The main purpose of any contract is to record the agreements of the parties to the transaction. But it often happens that one of the parties refuses to fulfill the agreement.

Termination of a contract and declaring it invalid are two different things. Each of the points has its own legal consequences.

By law, a dissatisfied participant must try to resolve the problem with the other participant peacefully - offer to terminate the contract in writing.

If a written refusal is received, or there is no response within 30 days, you can file a lawsuit.

When going to court, plaintiffs make a common mistake - they demand termination of the contract, but do not indicate demands for the return of money or property, then they have to file a second and third claim. It is enough to indicate all your demands in one claim.

You can also seek compensation for damages and moral damages.. The court will require evidence that the other party caused the plaintiff significant damages.

Video: Changing or terminating a real estate purchase and sale agreement

Hello, Natalia!

It is impossible to interrupt the transaction, since the agreement has already been concluded, that is, the transaction has taken place. Now each of the parties fulfills the obligations associated with the contract: the seller transfers the apartment, and the buyer transfers the money, if this has not already been done. In contrast to the previous norm of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Now registration of the purchase and sale agreement is not required. Only the transfer of rights is registered. Therefore, the purchase and sale agreement is considered concluded when the parties have agreed on all the essential terms of the transaction, and, of course, signed it, which is what happened in your case.

You can suspend the registration of the transfer of rights by sending a corresponding application to Rosreestr.

Regarding termination of the contract.

It is possible, before the execution of the contract, for example, before transferring money, to enter into a termination agreement, but if one of the parties does not agree, then to terminate (change) the contract you need to go to court.

As a general rule, unilateral termination of the contract, in our case at the initiative of the seller, without compelling reasons is not allowed.

Below are the legal norms of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation related to the termination of the contract:

Article 450. Grounds for amendment and termination of the contract
1. Amendments and termination of the contract are possible by agreement of the parties, unless otherwise provided by this Code, other laws or the contract.

2. At the request of one of the parties, the contract can be changed or terminated by a court decision only:

1) in case of a significant violation of the contract by the other party;

2) in other cases provided for by this Code, other laws or agreement.

A violation of the contract by one of the parties is considered significant, which entails such damage for the other party that it is significantly deprived of what it had the right to count on when concluding the contract.

3. In the event of a unilateral refusal to fulfill the contract in whole or in part, when such refusal is permitted by law or by agreement of the parties, the contract is considered respectively terminated or amended.

Article 451. Amendment and termination of the contract due to a significant change in circumstances
1. A significant change in the circumstances from which the parties proceeded when concluding the contract is the basis for its modification or termination, unless otherwise provided for by the contract or follows from its essence.

A change in circumstances is considered significant when they have changed so much that, if the parties could have reasonably foreseen it, the contract would not have been concluded by them at all or would have been concluded on significantly different terms.

2. If the parties have not reached an agreement to bring the contract into compliance with significantly changed circumstances or to terminate it, the contract may be terminated, and on the grounds provided for in paragraph 4 of this article, changed by the court at the request of the interested party if the following conditions are simultaneously present:

1) at the time of concluding the contract, the parties assumed that such a change in circumstances would not occur;

2) the change in circumstances was caused by reasons that the interested party could not overcome after their occurrence with the degree of care and prudence that was required of it by the nature of the contract and the conditions of turnover;

3) execution of the contract without changing its terms would so violate the relationship of property interests of the parties corresponding to the contract and would entail such damage for the interested party that it would largely lose what it had the right to count on when concluding the contract;

4) it does not follow from business customs or the essence of the contract that the risk of changes in circumstances is borne by the interested party.

3. When terminating a contract due to significantly changed circumstances, the court, at the request of either party, determines the consequences of terminating the contract, based on the need for a fair distribution between the parties of the costs incurred by them in connection with the execution of this contract.

4. Changing the contract due to a significant change in circumstances is permitted by a court decision in exceptional cases when termination of the contract is contrary to the public interest or will entail damage for the parties that significantly exceeds the costs necessary to execute the contract on the terms changed by the court.

Article 452. Procedure for amending and terminating the contract
1. An agreement to amend or terminate a contract is made in the same form as the contract, unless otherwise follows from the law, other legal acts, the contract or business customs.

2. A requirement to change or terminate a contract may be submitted by a party to the court only after receiving a refusal from the other party to the proposal to change or terminate the contract or failure to receive a response within the period specified in the proposal or established by law or the contract, and in its absence - within thirty days .

Article 453. Consequences of amendment and termination of the contract
1. If the contract is changed, the obligations of the parties remain unchanged.

2. Upon termination of the contract, the obligations of the parties cease.

3. In the event of a change or termination of the contract, obligations are considered changed or terminated from the moment the parties enter into an agreement on the change or termination of the contract, unless otherwise follows from the agreement or the nature of the change in the contract, and in case of change or termination of the contract in court - from the moment of entry into force the legal force of a court decision to amend or terminate the contract.

4. The parties do not have the right to demand the return of what they performed under the obligation before the change or termination of the contract, unless otherwise established by law or agreement of the parties.

5. If the basis for changing or terminating the contract was a significant violation of the contract by one of the parties, the other party has the right to demand compensation for losses caused by the change or termination of the contract.

If you can prove that the buyer violated the terms of the contract, you will be able to recover your losses from him, otherwise, the buyer may recover losses from you.

Therefore, it is preferable to conclude an agreement out of court.

Best regards, S. Sergeev

The purchase of real estate always comes with a contract. But the agreement can be terminated either at the request of the participants or if the conditions are not met.

Dear readers! The article talks about typical ways to resolve legal issues, but each case is individual. If you want to know how solve exactly your problem- contact a consultant:

APPLICATIONS AND CALLS ARE ACCEPTED 24/7 and 7 days a week.

It's fast and FOR FREE!

How to terminate a contract when buying or selling an apartment in 2019? Any agreement can be terminated under certain circumstances.

This also applies to documenting the purchase of a home. What is the procedure for terminating an apartment purchase and sale agreement in 2019?

Basic moments

It is impossible to demand the return of what has already been realized under obligations upon termination of the contract, unless otherwise predetermined by the terms of the transaction or the law.

The main consequences of the transaction termination procedure are based on this legal norm. For example, the buyer paid the amount under the contract, but never received the apartment.

The buyer has the right to demand because the condition for the transfer of the object of the transaction has not been met.

But at the same time, the seller is not at all obliged to return the money, since the obligation was fulfilled before the termination of the transaction. It turns out that the buyer will be left without money and without an apartment.

A clause on the return of money by the seller upon termination of the transaction will help to avoid such a situation.

Otherwise, the buyer will have to prove his case in court. Circumstances may be exactly the opposite, when the seller transfers the apartment, but does not receive money in return.

Termination of a transaction does not give the right to demand the return of property if this is not specified in the contract. thief

The seller is required to file a claim for payment under the contract, in the form of unjust enrichment and compensation for penalties due to late payment.

But a relative of the owner, who was previously registered in the apartment (before the court verdict), unexpectedly returns from prison and, through the court, seeks the opportunity to live again at the address of his previous registration. It is logical that the buyer does not want to buy such housing.

Legal grounds

Moreover, you will need to provide compelling arguments. Otherwise, the court will not be able to terminate the contract unless its terms or legal provisions are violated.

Agreement on termination of the apartment purchase and sale agreement

When drawing up an agreement to terminate the purchase and sale agreement, the parties must provide for all important nuances, writing them down in the terms of the agreement.

In particular, the agreement includes such clauses as:

  • details of the main agreement;
  • the date on which the contract terminates;
  • terms of termination;
  • the procedure for returning fulfilled obligations;
  • description of what is being returned;
  • return period;
  • payment of the penalty and its amount.

For example, a sample agreement to terminate the purchase and sale agreement for an apartment.

At the initiative of the seller

Any party can initiate termination of the contract. Initially, a pre-trial settlement will be required.

That is, the second party is given time to make a decision on voluntary termination. If a peaceful settlement is not possible, you can go to court and file a lawsuit.

The seller may request forced termination of the contract if:

If the buyer

The buyer can also unilaterally declare his desire to terminate the contract. The grounds are:

By agreement of the parties

By mutual agreement, the parties can terminate the transaction at any time. But there is a nuance associated with the form of the contract.

The form of the agreement should be similar. If the DCT was drawn up by a notary, then the agreement must be drawn up in notarial form.

In this case, the notary can, on behalf of the participants, submit an application to Rosreestr to terminate state registration.

Any of the participants can initiate the termination of the transaction. However, the grounds for termination are not regulated by law.

If the parties decide to terminate the contract, they can do so on any grounds. The process looks like this: one of the participants notifies the other party of his desire to terminate the contract.

When?

The limitation period for purchase and sale transactions is three years from the date of conclusion of the contract.

During this time, the parties to the transaction have the right to go to court with a demand to terminate the contract or declare it invalid.

In case of voluntary cancellation of a transaction, drawing up an agreement is possible until the terms of the contract are fulfilled in full.

Video: termination of a purchase and sale agreement at the initiative of the buyer

A reverse sale and purchase transaction can be concluded at any time, since it is an independent legal action.

It is also necessary to mention the period given to the parties to make a decision in the event of receiving notification of the desired termination from the other participant.

By default, this period is thirty days, but may be specified in the notification itself.

It is important to pay attention to such wording as “reasonable terms”, which relates to the time of transfer of property/money.

This period is not clearly regulated by law. Therefore, it is advisable to specify in the contract an exact deadline for fulfilling obligations under the contract.

Arbitrage practice

Termination of real estate purchase and sale agreements is accompanied by quite extensive judicial practice.

Most often, the reason is failure to fulfill the terms of the contract regarding the transfer of an apartment or money. The reason may also be the unexpected discovery of encumbrances.

But there are other situations as well. One could call them curious if their consequences were not so sad.

“The seller of the apartment approached the court with a demand to cancel the transaction two years after its conclusion. The reason was the alleged lack of payment.

A document written in clumsy handwriting was presented as evidence.

It stated that the seller undertakes to return the cost of the apartment if the contract does not pass state registration.

The buyer, in turn, provided evidence of full payment - witness testimony, a lease agreement for a safe deposit box, an act of access to the safe deposit box, a currency exchange order for the amount of the agreement.

But, nevertheless, the court came to the conclusion that payment was not made and decided to terminate the incompletely executed contract.”

There are situations that are hardly amenable to reasonable or legal explanation:

“The court was considering a case of termination of the purchase and sale agreement due to changed circumstances.

In particular, the plaintiff seller demanded to terminate the contract for the reason that his health had significantly deteriorated due to his advanced age and at the same time his financial situation had deteriorated.

Within one year, the plaintiff suffered a heart attack and stroke. That is, he could not imagine such a deterioration in his life.

The court considered the grounds to be the most significant changes that allow the contract to be terminated. The precedent is that eleven years have passed since the conclusion of the agreement.”

Only after registration with government agencies, an agreement on the purchase or sale of any real estate, including apartments, comes into force.

Sometimes it happens that a contract must be terminated for certain reasons. To achieve this, one of the parties can file a lawsuit, or an agreement can be reached voluntarily.

Basic provisions for termination of the contract

The contract terminates in any case when the termination procedure takes place. In addition, any legal relationship between the parties ends.

But to cancel the deal, one manifestation of will is not enough on the part of the seller or the buyer. You need to go to court or seek the consent of the opposite party.

The termination procedure itself takes place in the same form in which the contract was concluded from the very beginning. It means that everything must be done in writing.

In practice, the parties rarely, if ever, come to an agreement right away. Neither the seller nor the buyer can demand something if it was part of the obligations already fulfilled before the cancellation of the transaction.

The only exceptions are situations when such actions are provided for by the text of the contract itself.

In what cases can a purchase and sale agreement be terminated?

Article 450 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation is a document that precisely spells out all the grounds on which a transaction can be terminated. The main reason for this is serious violations by one of the parties.

There are several cases that are provided for by the legislation of the Russian Federation itself:

    Unseen circumstances. This means that reasons arise that make it impossible to comply with the conditions described in the contract.

    These reasons usually cannot be foreseen by either party. For example, they arise due to the interests of third parties;

    Another possible case is when the buyer provides partial payment or refuses it altogether.

    Such violations are usually committed by buyers after they have been registered in the State Register;

  • When a person or his family members refuse to move out of the apartment being sold. Or they are not deregistered.

Termination before registration

It will be much easier to complete this process if state registration has not yet completed.

If there is mutual agreement, all that remains is to sign the agreement itself between the parties.

Termination after registration

When the apartment has already been transferred to the buyer, resolving the issue is much more difficult.

Early termination of the transaction is possible in this case only on several grounds. They must be listed in the legislation or in the text of the contract itself. According to the Civil Code, The deal can only be canceled while the contract is in force.

It is not possible to terminate the contract when the transaction period has expired and all obligations have been fulfilled. This rule applies to any real estate transactions.

Property in principle not refunded upon termination of the contract, if the transaction was completed in part, but the state registration procedure for the transfer of authority to the apartment has already been carried out.

To be able to return absolutely everything corresponding the condition is stated either in the initial contract at the time of buying, or in the termination agreement.

Termination by agreement of the parties

You don’t have to go to court if you can reach mutual agreement. The filing of a claim by one of the parties becomes possible only if an official refusal is received from the second party.

One party must answer the other within a time limit no more than 30 days. The contract may specify other terms.

If you receive a refusal or no response at all, you will only have to go to court.

Termination through court

If it was not possible to reach an agreement, it is necessary to start drawing up a claim, after all negotiations and communications.

The main thing is to demand not only termination, but also return of property. Many people make the mistake of forgetting the second point.

The court makes a decision only on the basis of the claims presented by the plaintiff. He can terminate the contract, but will not decide the fate of the property that became its subject. You will have to submit the application again to satisfy another requirement.

Therefore, it is important to follow several basic rules:

  • You can demand compensation for moral damage if one of the parties committed a serious violation of the provisions specified in the law;
  • It is obligatory to indicate the return of the transferred property;
  • Termination of an agreement. It is necessary to indicate on what grounds this requirement is being put forward.

What to pay attention to

It is necessary to exercise maximum caution when completing any transaction in order to avoid complications in the future.

The agreement must include at least a couple of the following points:

  • The period during which funds will be transferred. It doesn’t matter whether this happens before registration is completed or after the corresponding action;
  • The very possibility of termination when one of the parties does not fulfill its obligations.

The deed of transfer most often becomes the main document, which records the very fact of transferring the apartment from one owner to another.

You can use another form to formalize this fact. The apartment will be considered transferred after the signing of all papers and the actual transfer of property.

But even the legislation does not establish specific deadlines within which this action must be completed. The Civil Code of the Russian Federation offers only one concept - reasonable terms. This is a very conditional concept, and therefore it is better to provide for the relevant conditions in advance, in the text of the contract itself.

Invalid and terminated transactions are completely different concepts. But as a result of each of these actions, the contract ceases to be valid. The responsibilities of each party also lose their relevance.

But, if the transaction is declared invalid, the consequences will be different than for termination. The guilty party as a result returns everything that was received as a result of concluding the original contract.

If necessary, the perpetrators also compensate for the damage caused by their actions. This is stated in Article 167 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

There are several cases for declaring any transaction invalid:

    A feigned or imaginary transaction.

    The first option is when it is concluded to cover up other relationships, the second is when no legal consequences are created;

    Concluding a contract under grave circumstances such as conspiracy, violence, deception, and so on.

    There will be difficulties in recognizing the invalidity of a transaction if fraud has occurred.

    It is better to also contact the police to open a criminal case against the persons guilty of the crime;

    One of the parties to the agreement has lost the ability to consciously direct their actions.

    This refers to a situation where a person is not aware of his decisions at a certain moment - namely, when an agreement is signed;

  • The seller or buyer is recognized as incompetent or of limited capacity;
  • Regulations and rules of law are violated.

The validity of a particular transaction is disputed if it turns out that the organization that owns the apartment does not have its statutory documents correctly drawn up. For example, when a contract is signed by a person who did not have any authority to do so. Or if the transaction was registered, but the managers did not approve it.

Payment for any product is the responsibility of the buyer, the main condition for the validity of the agreement between him and the seller. Most often, mistakes in this case are made when preparing payment documents. For example, it is recommended to carry out only cashless payments if an organization acts as a seller.

The receipt and act must confirm the fact of the transaction if the object is purchased from an individual. In the receipt you need to write what amount was transferred, by whom, to whom and for what.

Many people believe that in order for an agreement to come into force, it is enough to draw up the paperwork with a notary. But this belief does not correspond to reality.

Any object can have its flaws, but sometimes there are too many of them. We can list only the most common problems:

  • Basic real estate documents are not transferred;
  • Registration of citizens who cannot be discharged;
  • Encumbrance with the rights of third parties, use as collateral;
  • The technical condition is worse than originally specified in the contract.

The law says that such shortcomings must be discussed in advance, either when meeting with the buyer orally, or in the text of the contract itself. But in this case, real estate properties will cost much less.

First of all, buyers can demand a price reduction or termination of the contract in court if they purchased an object to which third parties have rights. This position is enshrined in Article 460 of the Civil Code.

Any person can refuse the contract even if the seller does not provide the entire set with the necessary documents.

There are various options for action when selling goods with a low level of quality. For example, it is permissible to request a replacement.

The conclusion of preliminary agreements is necessary if sellers receive a certain advance. This agreement specifies when full payment must be made.

And the responsibility of each party is mentioned if they do not fulfill their obligations:

    A notary is usually responsible for document preparation in this situation.

    But there is nothing illegal if both parties draw up the papers in their own hands;

  • The buyer must notify the seller in writing if for some reason he cannot transfer the entire amount within the previously established period. In the same letter you can ask for a delay;

    • The seller returns the deposit to the buyer in an increased amount if he does not agree to such actions, regardless of the reasons for the refusal. After this, a fine is paid, which should be directly stated in the text of the contract.

    It is this point that most often causes litigation;

    The buyer needs to write an application to the arbitration court if the seller has found more favorable conditions for the sale and does not want to waste time waiting.

    The statement indicates the reasons why the misunderstanding arose;

  • But in such a situation, there is a possibility of receiving only the amount that served as an advance;
  • You will also have to go to court if, for some reason, the buyer refuses to proceed with the transaction.

When completing transactions, it is better to involve experienced specialists. After all, not every person without professional education will be able to understand absolutely all the intricacies.

Many years of practice and higher legal education will be a guarantee for both parties and will save money and time.